Taming the Beast: Avoiding Common Mistakes When Brewing

In the world of specialty coffee, "freshness" is the holy grail. We spend a lot of time talking about roast dates and avoiding stale, supermarket beans. However, there is a lesser-known truth in the industry: fresh coffee can actually be quite difficult to work with.

When you buy high-quality, freshly roasted coffee beans, you are dealing with a volatile, chemically active ingredient. It is alive with gas and changing every single day. While the potential for flavour is incredible, these beans can be unruly. If you treat them exactly the same way you treat older, settled beans, you might end up with a cup that tastes sour, metallic, or uneven.

Here's how to navigate the science of freshness and avoid the most common brewing pitfalls.

Mistake 1: Brewing Too Soon (The "Resting" Phase)

The biggest mistake enthusiasts make is opening the bag the second it arrives on the doorstep. It is natural to be excited, but brewing coffee on the day it was roasted (or even the day after) is rarely a good idea.

During roasting, complex chemical reactions build up a massive amount of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) inside the cellular structure of the bean. If you brew immediately, two things happen:

1. Carbonic Acid: When that excessive CO2 hits hot water, it can create carbonic acid, which imparts a sharp, sour, and metallic taste to the cup. This often masks the sweet, fruitier notes of the origin.

2. Extraction Blockage: The gas pushing out of the coffee prevents the water from getting in. It acts as a barrier, leading to uneven extraction.

The Fix:
You need to let the beans "rest" or degas.

• Filter/Pour-Over: Wait at least 3 to 5 days after the roast date.

• Espresso: Wait 7 to 10 days. Espresso brewing is high-pressure, which amplifies the carbonic acid effect. The crema will be uncontrollably thick and bubbly (mostly gas, not oils) and the shot will likely taste sour.

Mistake 2: Skipping or Rushing the Bloom

If you are brewing filter coffee (like a V60, Chemex, or Plunger), the "bloom" is the most critical step for fresh beans. The bloom is the initial pour of water that wets the grounds and allows the gas to escape—often looking like a bubbling volcano.

A common mistake is pouring all the water at once. Because fresh beans have so much trapped gas, pouring continuously creates a chaotic environment. The water will channel around the gas pockets rather than soaking into the coffee particles. This leads to "channeling," where some coffee is over-extracted (bitter) and some is under-extracted (sour).

The Fix:
Pour roughly twice the weight of water as there is coffee (e.g., 30g of water for 15g of coffee). Then, wait.
For older beans, a 30-second bloom is fine. For fresh beans, you might need to wait 45 to 60 seconds until the bubbling completely settles. You must wait for the gas to leave before the real brewing begins.

Mistake 3: Relying on Volumetric Scoops

Fresh coffee beans are physically larger and less dense than stale beans. As coffee ages and loses gas and moisture, it shrinks slightly and settles.

If you use a scoop to measure your coffee, one scoop of fresh beans will actually contain less coffee by weight than one scoop of older beans. This throws off your ratio. You might think you are brewing your standard recipe, but you are actually using less coffee, resulting in a weak, watery cup.

The Fix:
Always use a digital scale. Weighing your dose (in grams) is the only way to ensure consistency. 20 grams is 20 grams, regardless of whether the bean was roasted yesterday or last month.

Mistake 4: Storing in the Hopper

If you have a home espresso machine or a grinder with a hopper, it is tempting to fill it up with your entire bag of fresh beans. This is a significant error.

The hopper is not an airtight environment. It is usually clear plastic, which exposes the beans to light, and it is not sealed, exposing them to constant airflow. Fresh beans degrade much faster in a hopper than they do in their original bag. Furthermore, the heat from the espresso machine often rises up into the hopper, essentially "cooking" the oils in the beans and making them go stale within days.

The Fix:
Keep your beans in the resealable bag they came in, or an opaque, airtight canister. Only put the specific amount of beans you need for that specific brew into the hopper.

Mistake 5: Not Adjusting Grind Size

Fresh beans are more brittle and harder than aged beans. As they age, they absorb moisture from the air and become slightly softer.

This means fresh beans shatter differently in the grinder. They often produce more "fines" (microscopic dust) which can clog up your filter or espresso basket. If you use the exact same grind setting you used for your last bag (which was likely a few weeks old by the time you finished it), you might find your fresh coffee "chokes" the machine or drains too slowly.

The Fix:
Be prepared to dial in your grinder. Fresh beans often require a slightly coarser grind setting to allow the water to flow through the vigorous degassing action.

Troubleshooting Freshness

The following table can help you identify if "freshness" is the cause of your bad brew.

Brewing Better with The Blind Coffee Roaster

Brewing with fresh coffee is a skill, but it is one worth mastering. The vibrancy, aroma, and complexity of a fresh roast are things you simply cannot replicate with supermarket coffee. This is where The Blind Coffee Roaster becomes your partner in the process.

We take pride in roasting high-quality beans and getting them to you fast, ensuring you have the best possible raw material to work with. By understanding the science of resting, blooming, and weighing, you can unlock the full potential of our roasted beans. It might take a little extra patience, but when you hit that sweet spot, the result is the best coffee experience you can have at home or in your shop.

Subscribe to The Blind Coffee Roaster today.